Tesla Supercharger vs Electrify America: Speed Comparison 2024
Compare the two largest fast-charging networks in North America. Learn about charging speeds, costs, coverage, and which network is best for your EV.
Network Overview
Tesla Supercharger
- • Locations: 50,000+ globally, 6,000+ in North America
- • Max Speed: Up to 250 kW (V3), 150 kW (V2)
- • Connector: Tesla proprietary (NACS)
- • Reliability: 99.95% uptime
- • Payment: Integrated billing
Electrify America
- • Locations: 3,500+ chargers, 800+ stations
- • Max Speed: Up to 350 kW
- • Connector: CCS1 (SAE Combo)
- • Reliability: ~95% uptime
- • Payment: App, RFID, credit card
Charging Speed Comparison
| Vehicle | Tesla Supercharger | Electrify America | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tesla Model 3 | 250 kW peak | 170 kW peak | Tesla |
| Tesla Model Y | 250 kW peak | 170 kW peak | Tesla |
| Hyundai IONIQ 5 | N/A (adapter needed) | 235 kW peak | EA |
| Kia EV6 | N/A (adapter needed) | 239 kW peak | EA |
| Ford Mustang Mach-E | N/A (adapter needed) | 150 kW peak | EA |
| Lucid Air | N/A (adapter needed) | 300 kW peak | EA |
Cost Comparison
Pricing Structure
Tesla Supercharger
- • Tesla owners: $0.25-$0.50/kWh
- • Non-Tesla: $0.48-$0.60/kWh
- • Membership available for non-Tesla
- • Time-based pricing during peak hours
Electrify America
- • Guest: $0.43-$0.48/kWh
- • Pass+ members: $0.36-$0.40/kWh
- • Pass members: $0.31-$0.35/kWh
- • Some locations have per-minute pricing
Network Coverage
Tesla Supercharger Advantages
- ✅ Massive network with excellent coverage
- ✅ Consistent high reliability
- ✅ Seamless integration with Tesla vehicles
- ✅ Premium locations (hotels, shopping centers)
- ✅ Real-time availability in Tesla navigation
Electrify America Advantages
- ✅ Higher peak charging speeds (up to 350 kW)
- ✅ Open to all CCS-compatible vehicles
- ✅ Strategic highway corridor placement
- ✅ Multiple connector types at each station
- ✅ Competitive pricing with membership plans
Real-World Performance
Charging Time Examples (10-80%)
Tesla Model 3 (75 kWh)
Supercharger: 28 minutes
EA: 35 minutes
Hyundai IONIQ 5 (77.4 kWh)
Supercharger: N/A*
EA: 22 minutes
Ford Mustang Mach-E (88 kWh)
Supercharger: N/A*
EA: 45 minutes
*Requires NACS adapter (coming 2024-2025)
Which Network Should You Choose?
Choose Tesla Supercharger If:
- • You drive a Tesla vehicle
- • You prioritize reliability and uptime
- • You want the largest network coverage
- • You prefer seamless, integrated charging experience
- • You frequently travel long distances
Choose Electrify America If:
- • You drive a non-Tesla EV with CCS connector
- • Your vehicle supports ultra-fast charging (>200 kW)
- • You want the fastest possible charging speeds
- • You prefer competitive pricing with membership options
- • You primarily travel on major highway corridors
Future Outlook
NACS Adoption
Major automakers including Ford, GM, Rivian, and others are adopting Tesla's NACS connector standard. This means:
- • Non-Tesla EVs will gain access to Supercharger network (2024-2025)
- • Adapters will be available for existing CCS vehicles
- • Tesla Supercharger network will become the de facto standard
- • Competition will increase, potentially lowering prices
Calculate Your Charging Time
Want to know exactly how long it will take to charge your specific EV? Use our calculator to get precise charging times for both networks.
Calculate Charging Time